Advertising on the portal

Do I need a Komarovsky air humidifier in summer? A Brief Review of the Best Humidifiers for Kids' Health

When a person coughs, unpleasant symptoms are tormented. This process is especially difficult for children: they become capricious, lose their appetite, and do not sleep well. Many doctors claim that they appear due to the very dry air in the room and recommend moistening it.

However, sometimes high humidity causes an increase in seizures. This article will discuss whether a humidifier can cause a cough and why?

AT winter period time, many are faced with the fact that the air in their apartments or houses is too dry. Because of this, irritations in the nasopharynx begin, a cough may appear in combination with colds or infectious diseases.

It is very important to ensure that the air is not too dry., since in this case the cough will be dry for a long time, sputum will not be able to come out and the person will get complications in the form of or.

To do this, it is necessary to ventilate the room, do wet cleaning. Today, special devices that humidify dry air are very popular.

Pediatricians believe that a humidifier when a child coughs has only positive effects. However, this is not always the case such devices have their drawbacks:

  • when using ultrasonic air humidification, a person develops a strong cough, body temperature rises, severe complications develop;
  • very often on the furniture you can see white traces of plaque;
  • water must be changed every day;
  • if the appliance is not in use, it must be completely dry inside;
  • be sure to treat with special antimicrobial agents.

Very often, a person is faced with the fact that he suddenly developed a cough from a humidifier, his body temperature rises. These problems appear spontaneously, and also disappear after stopping the use of the device. What could be the reason for this, and what measures should be taken?

Opinion and advice of Dr. Komarovsky on cough from a humidifier in children

As mentioned above, pediatricians advise the use of humidifiers when treating coughs in young children.

They have undeniable positive aspects, help and contribute to the rapid recovery of the baby. What does Dr. Komarovsky think about this?

Evgeny Olegovich claims that with ARVI in a child air humidity should be at least 50-70%, otherwise the risk of complications increases.

To maintain this indicator in the norm, he recommends using a special ultrasonic humidifier. Today, there are many brands and manufacturers of these devices and everyone can find the right one for him.

In this case, it is very important to follow all the points of the instructions for the devices: regularly change replaceable cartridges, water, wash the device. This will help reduce the risk of pathogens growing inside the humidifier.

In principle, when used correctly, an ultrasonic humidifier does not cause any complications. The appearance or intensification of coughing fits is possible only if the device is used improperly. In this case, it is recommended to give water from it to the sanitary-epidemiological laboratory for bacteriological analysis.

In case of detection of pathogenic microflora, it is necessary to disinfect the humidifier and the room in which it is used. Therefore, the question of why coughing from a humidifier can be given an unequivocal answer: due to improper operation of the device.

When not worth saving, it is better to give preference good producers. This fact is especially important in the treatment of young patients, since the risk of complications in this case is very high.

In addition to humidifiers, you can increase the level of humidity in the room with the help of regular ventilation, wet cleaning.

You can also hang a damp towel on the batteries, which, as it dries, will humidify the air in the room. by the most in a simple way remains spraying with water from a conventional spray bottle. This can be done together with the child in the form of a game.

Conclusion

The level of humidity in the room occupies a very important place in the treatment of colds and infectious diseases. To control this indicator, it is recommended to hang a special hygrometer in the room. Experts recommend using special ultrasonic humidifiers, which help to reach the required level of 50-70%.

At the same time, it is imperative to fulfill all the requirements for their operation, regularly change the water and treat with disinfectant solutions. Only in this case, these devices bring positive results and reduce the risk of complications.

For the first time, we seriously thought about the humidity of the air in our apartment after reading the book by Dr. Komarovsky, respected by us, “Health of the child and common sense his relatives”, preparing for the birth of our son. No, we, of course, have noticed before that many of our indoor flowers, with which all our windows are filled, do not survive until the end of the heating season, but we did not take any active steps to correct the situation. Dr. Komarovsky writes that the optimal relative room should be 50-70% (better than 60%, and for a patient with a respiratory infection - 70%), but in winter during the heating season, indoor air humidity is usually two times lower than recommended. Therefore, when making repairs in the apartment, we installed regulators on the batteries and thought that this would solve the problem. But, despite the regulators, as well as the two aquariums with fish that we have, we realized that the problem was not completely solved. The flowers began to feel better, but still not good enough, the water in the aquarium continued to evaporate, although a little slower than before. The child often asked for water, the nasal mucosa dried up and we often got sick with SARS. Therefore, I was delighted when they brought us the Philips HU4802/01 humidifier.

My son was also happy and wanted to open the box as soon as possible. First of all, we read the instructions and chose a suitable place for installation. We didn’t think of anything better than putting the device on a wide window sill in the bedroom, because you need to find a place so that the child does not knock over the humidifier. The window in the bedroom overlooks the loggia, and the radiator does not fry much, it is muted to maintain the optimum temperature in the apartment at 21 degrees Celsius.

The device is easy to use and the instructions are clear. They poured water, connected it to the outlet, turned on the device itself. The sensors are clear and understandable: you can adjust humidity, speed, set a timer. When the desired air humidity is reached, the indicator will glow blue, and then the device will simply maintain this humidity.

It turned out that the humidity in the apartment is not quite low, about 40%, but I wanted more. Humidity of 50% was reached after 9 hours. But since our beloved doctor believes that it is better to keep the air humidity at 60%, we decided not to stop there. Since then, for the past three weeks, we have been trying to reach a humidity of 60%, but apparently this will not happen quickly: a three-room apartment, interior doors do not close and at first all objects in our apartment should be saturated with moisture. In addition, when we go for a walk, we turn off the humidifier, open the window and ventilate the apartment.

Now, twice a day, we fill the humidifier with tap water (you can fill it in two ways: bring and pour water into it from a certain container, or pour directly into the bowl of the humidifier from the tap).

If the water in the device runs out, then the indicator starts flashing in advance, informing about it, and when it runs out completely, the device turns off, i.e. "Protection from a fool" is available and works (verified). At night, we turn on the silent mode (although it is not very noisy in normal mode, it makes much quieter noise than our aquariums). Once every two weeks, it is recommended to rinse the water bowl and filter, which is not at all burdensome.

Flaws? So far, I haven't been able to find them! Unless there is a scoreboard with information about which this moment air humidity environment. But we can fix it! Firstly, I know that Philips has another humidifier model with such an information board, and secondly, you can simply purchase a hygrometer.

So, after three weeks of using the Philips HU4802/01 humidifier, we managed to achieve a relative humidity of more than 50% in the apartment. It became easier to breathe, you feel yourself on the Mediterranean coast. The nasal mucosa does not dry out, our child walks without snot! The water in the aquarium began to evaporate much more slowly, and the flowers began to feel noticeably better, I even began to water them less often, only once a week. I am glad that we have such a device!

How did people ever live without a humidifier? Well, before there were no disposable diapers and automatic washing machines. In the apartment, from morning to evening, they washed, boiled and dried diapers constantly, thus increasing the humidity of the environment. However, even now you can do without a humidifier: often do wet cleaning and rinse your nose, use a spray bottle, put open water containers around the apartment, install aquariums and decorative fountains. But getting and using a humidifier is much easier!

Many people neglect such an indicator as the humidity in the house, and in vain, because it directly affects the well-being and health of households. This is especially true for children. Therefore, it is necessary to think about how to optimize this indicator. To do this, you should think about how to choose a humidifier for a child's room.

In contact with

What gives the installation of such equipment

In children skin covering very gentle. And the smaller the baby, the more sensitive his skin to various irritants. Often she suffers from dry air.

In such cases, the skin dries up, begins to peel off and even become inflamed. Also low indoor humidity. adversely affects the respiratory tract.

This manifests itself, which somewhat complicates normal breathing. As a result, an allergic reaction, frequent colds, as well as whims and crying.

Many people think about whether a humidifier is needed in the apartment. Why waste money? It is worth considering that dry air leads to the following consequences:

  • peeling and irritation of the skin;
  • drying of the mucous membranes of the mouth and nose;
  • the risk of allergies;
  • infectious diseases of the respiratory tract;
  • the occurrence of colic and violation of the chair.

A humidifier for the home will solve all these problems and create optimal conditions for the baby. As studies show, when normal conditions the child behaves more calmly, sleeps well and is less sick.

The device will become indispensable in the winter, when hot batteries and heaters significantly reduce humidity in a closed space. In some cases, the figure can reach 20%. This is very bad, since such conditions are inherent in the desert. Of course, this is not the limit. Humidity can drop even lower if materials that absorb moisture were used to decorate the room.

In such conditions, it is quite dangerous for a child to stay. Low humidity adversely affects health. Therefore, parents should seriously think about creating the optimal microclimate for the baby. A humidifier for children will quickly solve the problem of dryness in the room.

What to consider when choosing

When choosing a humidifier for a child's room, it is worth considering the following parameters:

  • safety during operation;
  • noise level;
  • price;
  • operating features.

There is a wide range of equipment on the market today. This will allow everyone create an optimal microclimate in the house.

Especially popular are cheap models equipped with all the necessary functions.

In defense of compact devices, it is worth mentioning the economy.

They consume little electricity. But what better option for a child?

Among the popular models, it is worth highlighting the following humidifiers:

  1. Traditional. It is very easy to operate, consumes relatively little electricity and does not make noise during operation. To improve efficiency, it is recommended to install it near heat sources or in places with good air circulation. Silent humidifier is ideal for a nursery.
  2. Aerosol. In progress sprays water particles. Equipped with devices that are responsible for measuring humidity and turning off equipment if necessary. It makes quite a lot of noise during operation.
  3. Steam. During operation, the water heats up, resulting in the release of steam. In the future, it spreads throughout the room. The disadvantage is that the technique consumes a lot of electricity. This should be taken into account when deciding which air humidifier is better, ultrasonic or steam.
  4. Ultrasonic. It is small in size, does not make noise and can serve spacious rooms. Moisture spraying can be carried out simultaneously in several directions.
  5. Air wash. The device is equipped with a rod that is coated with silver. This allows you to purify the water used from various viruses and bacteria.
  6. Humidifier with ionizer. It not only increases moisture, but also cleans the air from dust and various substances. Some models are equipped with ultraviolet lamps that disinfect the room.

Also, when choosing, it is worth considering consumer reviews and the rating of air humidifiers. Let's take a closer look at some popular options. This will help a lot when choosing humidifiers for the nursery.

Ultrasonic devices

Today there are various air conditioning equipment. Models differ in structure, principle of operation and technical characteristics.

Among the popular options, it is worth highlighting ultrasonic devices that are highly efficient. Evaporation of water takes place under the influence of vibrations of a special membrane.

It is located directly in the water tank, which eliminates any accidents.

Note! Technique for increasing air humidity is picky about water. It is best to use purified liquid for this. It can be purchased at the store or obtained as a result of filtering at home.

Ultrasonic humidifier for newborns has many advantages:

  • allows you to easily increase the humidity in the room;
  • work very quietly;
  • devices with high power are able to serve a large area;
  • easy to move as it is small;
  • in a fairly short time creates an optimal microclimate in the room.

Traditional Humidifiers

Instruments provide natural moisture increase in room. They work quite slowly, especially when it comes to servicing a large room. Initially, moisture is absorbed into the floor, wallpaper and interior items. In the future, it remains only to maintain the humidity at the desired level. This is worth considering before choosing a humidifier for an apartment.

The device and the principle of operation of the device are quite simple. The tank contains a filter through which air is supplied. It is blown by fans.

At the exit, the air masses are saturated with moisture. The peculiarity of the device is that the filter also cleans them. Given this, he himself needs periodic cleaning.

This can be easily done on your own. Once a year, experts recommend complete replacement of the filter element.

Often the fan is installed on top of the case. During operation, it makes a certain noise that causes discomfort. Of course, this indicator depends on the technical characteristics and device of the humidifier itself.

Despite this, this type of humidifier for newborns has significant advantages:

  • low cost;
  • ease of use;
  • the ability to use ordinary tap water;
  • efficiency.

This is quite enough to think about installing such models in the children's room.

Air wash

Air washer or humidifier, which is better? The principle of operation of the first is somewhat similar to the previous models of the classical type. The difference is that they do not have a filter that needs to be cleaned and changed regularly. The device is working due to the disks that are in the water tank. During operation, a fan blows on them. The plates have a fairly large surface, which ensures rapid moistening of the air masses throughout the room.

Another feature of sinks is that they effectively clean the space from allergens and dust.

During the operation of the unit, they fall on the surface of the disks, from where they are washed off with water into the pan. Some models are equipped with an ionization function.

This improves the quality of air mass filtration. The process occurs due to static electricity.

To decide how to choose a humidifier for an apartment, you need to consider that sinks have some advantages:

  • silent operation;
  • high efficiency;
  • the ability to use in spacious rooms;
  • able to work on any water.

As for the shortcomings, here it is necessary to take into account the rather high cost of equipment and significant size.

Climate complexes

Such aggregates are indeed whole complexes, which consist of various functional elements.

Available words are stationary humidifier equipped with additional filter elements.

In this case, conventional evaporative filters or aerodynamic structures are used.

Thanks to additional filters, the space can be cleared of dust, unpleasant odors, smog and allergens.

  • silent operation;
  • high functionality;
  • ease of maintenance;
  • efficiency in terms of humidification and air purification.

Note! Such units are quite expensive, this must be remembered when choosing a humidifier for a child's room. To decide which option is better, it is necessary to take into account all the features and specifications available models.

A humidifier is an indispensable attribute of a child's room, it will allow you to create the perfect microclimate for your baby. Ideally, all premises of the house should be equipped with such devices, the health of all family members, regardless of age, depends on this.

Useful video: Dr. Komarovsky's advice on choosing a humidifier

In contact with

  • sleeping badly
  • daytime sleep
  • Tantrums

    • The correct air humidity in the room where the child lives allows not only to provide him with protection from viruses and allergies, but also to recover faster if the illness does happen. This was repeatedly told to parents by a respected pediatrician and author of many books and articles on children's health Evgeny Komarovsky.

    Many mothers and fathers, listening to the doctor's advice, try to humidify the air in the children's room with the help of basins of water, an aquarium, steam, wet towels hung on radiators. Sooner or later, the understanding comes that it is easier and more profitable to purchase a special device - an air humidifier. Evgeny Komarovsky tells how to choose it and how to use it correctly.

    Benefit and harm

    The mucous membranes of the nose and nasopharynx perform important protective functions. They produce mucus that can bind viruses and slow their spread.

    If the mucus dries up due to the fact that the child breathes dry air or breathes through the mouth during a runny nose, then the biological fluid that has changed its consistency becomes dangerous for the baby. Pathogenic bacteria begin to feel great in dried nasal mucus.

    Many parents have noticed that the current snot one day turns into thick and green. This is the result of improper air humidity.

    A child who constantly breathes dry air is more likely to suffer from acute respiratory viral infections.

    During illness, they have a significantly higher risk of complications. The fact is that if, when coughing in the bronchi, which also actively produce a protective secret against viruses, bronchial mucus begins to dry out, this will most likely lead to bronchitis. If dried mucus begins to interfere with pulmonary metabolism, then pneumonia will begin.

    Moist air during the flu or SARS is generally one of the main “medicines”: viral infections recede faster, and the immune system learns to recognize viruses and resist them when the patient breathes humid air, drinks a lot of liquids. At the same time, you usually do not need to buy any other medicines from a pharmacy.

    Children who breathe insufficiently humidified air are more likely to suffer from various allergic reactions. They are more difficult to bear high temperature that accompanies various diseases, they get sick longer, their immunity is much weaker than their peers who breathe air with relative humidity ranging from 50 to 70%. It is this level of humidity that Komarovsky recommends maintaining for the children's room.

    To find out how much the air in the room is saturated with moisture, you should take a device - a hygrometer. If the indicator does not “reach” up to 50%, then you should think about purchasing a humidifier. It will help, without too much fuss, running around with basins, jars of water and wet towels, to create the right microclimate in which the child will grow up healthy.

    Harm from the humidifier will only be if the parents grossly violate the rules for its operation. If there is a humidity in the child's room that exceeds 75-80%, then this will negatively affect his well-being and health.

    Types of humidifiers - pros and cons

    There are three types of humidifiers on the market today:

    1. steam;
    2. ultrasonic;
    3. "cold".

    Steam humidifiers are similar to kettles in terms of operation: in order for the water to begin to evaporate, it is heated to a boil in the device by two electrodes. This is the cheapest and affordable option home appliances.

    When choosing a steam humidifier, you should make sure that it is equipped with a special humidity sensor, which instructs the device to turn off immediately after the desired set humidity is reached in the room. If this is not included in the humidifier, then you will have to buy it separately, which is not very convenient and expensive.

    Among the disadvantages of the steam appliance can be indicated high level energy consumption. But otherwise, this type of humidifier is very suitable for children's rooms - it is the most productive, quickly creates the desired microclimate, there is no need to buy consumables for it. The product works simply: water is poured and the container is plugged into an outlet.

    It should be remembered that humidification occurs with hot steam, and therefore it is necessary to place the humidifier so that the child cannot reach it under any circumstances.

    Ultrasonic humidifiers are more expensive than steam humidifiers, but they have more benefits. So, with lower power consumption, these devices show a fairly high performance.

    The principle of operation of such a device is more complex: ultrasonic radiation is applied to the piezoelectric crystal, electrical vibrations become mechanical. The advantage of this technique is in its small dimensions, the mobility of the atomizer, with which steam can be directed from any direction.

    With all the advantages, ultrasonic humidifiers are quite capricious: if too hard water is often poured into them, the filter quickly fails. This can lead to the fact that a white precipitate will fall on furniture and wallpaper. In addition, replacement filters for appliances are expensive.

    "Cold" humidifiers are the most expensive. They got this name for the principle of operation, according to which the dry air that is currently in the room, entering the inside of the device, is cleaned. Inside there is a wet cartridge, passing through which the air cools and is saturated with moisture.

    The performance of such equipment directly depends on the initial humidity. The higher it is, the slower the device will work, because there is no point in intensive moisturizing. Therefore, such a "smart" humidifier will always support optimal level humidity itself, without the intervention of household members.

    Such a device is very demanding on the quality of the water that will wet the filter. Too hard water will damage the filter. Therefore, it is better to use distilled water or, for extra money, buy special cartridges that “know how” to soften hard water and demineralize it.

    This humidifier does not release streams of steam, like the previous two types, and therefore the child will not be interested. Another advantage is that the humidifier not only saturates the air with water, but also purifies it, since it works with smaller particles.

    Cold humidifiers consume the same amount of electricity as ultrasonic humidifiers. However, their performance is lower than that of ultrasonic ones, but they are on self-regulation.

    The disadvantage of the device is that it is not able to raise the relative humidity above 60%. In addition, the filter service life is no more than 3 months, so consumables will have to be purchased and changed at least 4 times a year.

    Where to start choosing

    You should start choosing a device for a nursery by measuring the room.

    You must come to the store with a piece of paper, which will indicate:

    • room area;
    • ceiling height;
    • a brief description of the type of room (how many windows, what the walls are made of, how many in the room upholstered furniture, plants).

    It is also advisable to tell the seller how often you can change the water in the appliance. If you are sitting at home, then the tank may be small, but if the parents are at work all day and the child is in the kindergarten, then it is better to take the device with large capacity to add water less often.

    Yevgeny Komarovsky claims that the most difficult thing when choosing in a store is to evaluate the noise effects that a humidifier emits. In the space of a large shopping center none of the devices seem to make noise. But after all, it will be used in the bedroom, including working at night. It is important that the device is as quiet as possible.

    If you have to choose a humidifier for the first time, you should not immediately take an expensive and technologically complex model, says Komarovsky. Beginners do not need an instance with a control panel, an “on-board computer”, and a host of additional functions. To begin with, you just need to understand how the device is used and why this particular family needs it.

    Does a humidifier help if a child is sick? How often should it be turned on? And which one is better to choose - with hot steam, with cold, with an ionizer?

    It's not a humidifier that helps, it's the right humidity. In the room where there is a child with any variant of acute respiratory infections, relative humidity air should be between 50 and 70%. If the air is dry (or even more dangerous - dry and warm), this greatly increases the risk of complications and prevents the body from fighting viruses and bacteria. It goes without saying that it is absolutely impossible to maintain optimal air humidity, especially at the height of the heating season, without special devices. The best such device is a humidifier. The safest, most convenient, silent and efficient ultrasonic humidifier. The use of a humidifier is not an end in itself, it must be turned on exactly when the air humidity drops below 50%. And turn off when it is above 70%.

    How to humidify the air and ventilate the room at the same time? As soon as the window closes, the temperature becomes 25-26 degrees. Opening the window, moisten the street.

    Unfortunately, at low air temperatures outside, it is almost impossible to ventilate the room and leave the air in the room moist. Therefore, in winter time to achieve a decrease in the temperature in the room should be mainly by acting on the heat source - the battery. It is necessary to turn on the faucet, if there is one, in extreme cases, close the battery with a thick blanket, foam plastic or anything that your imagination is enough for. This will allow you to maintain the optimum temperature in the room without constantly opening the windows.

    We have such a situation. Last week, my husband and I raised the issue of purchasing a humidifier for the group in the kindergarten. We agreed on the issue with the educator and the nurse. Everyone was not against it, and the nurse even said that a humidifier was needed. We were even ready to pay half the cost ourselves (the rest of the parents would have chipped in too). The birth was to take place tomorrow. meeting. Now the husband came from the kindergarten and said that the nurse called the sanitary and epidemiological station, and they said literally: “You can’t use humidifiers in the kindergarten, because it can be harmful to some children. Better buy a quartz lamp. It is clear that this issue will never be raised in the kindergarten, because who wants to conflict with the sanitary and epidemiological station. And we wanted to send our youngest child to kindergarten in the spring :(
    Are there really any orders or laws of the Ministry of Health related to these humidifiers, or is it all taken from the ceiling to remove responsibility? I don’t know if the nurse coordinated this issue with the Kharkiv or Dergachev sanitary and epidemiological station. We live in Dergachi. So what's now? No one will be especially persistent and run around the authorities, there is no time.

    There are no orders-laws specifically relating to humidifiers, and cannot exist.
    It is not the presence of a humidifier that is regulated, but the indicators of air humidity. And the sanitation station, and the children, and the parents, and even personally Dr. Komarovsky absolutely do not care if there is a humidifier in the kindergarten or not. The main thing is that the humidity of the air meets the standards.
    You, or rather the staff kindergarten, you can provide the necessary (regulated by the sanitation station) humidity in any way you like: you can often wash the floors, you can hang wet towels on the radiators, you can walk around with a spray bottle all day. You, in the end, can take advantage of the achievements of civilization and purchase a humidifier.
    Humidifier cannot be contraindicated for anyone (“harmful for some children”). Air humidity that does not correspond to the norm may be contraindicated.
    What is the whole horror of what is happening in general and what you described in particular:
    - a nurse (!!) is not afraid to demonstrate her own illiteracy and calls the SES, where anonymous consultants demonstrate even greater illiteracy;
    - parents trust the health of their children to such "specialists";
    - to achieve normal air for their children means "to conflict with the sanitary and epidemiological station."
    It is especially sad that all these especially wise "prohibitors" remain unknown and unpunished.
    And here's to find out:
    - number and location of the kindergarten;
    - the name of the especially caring nurse;
    - the name and position of an unknown consultant from the SES.
    And I would forward this information to the appropriate authorities. And we would (maybe) wait for an answer.
    And there would be less for one consultant, since it is easy to be smart on the phone, but it is difficult to be responsible for your words.
    Is ultrasound harmful? In medicine and in everyday life? I was given an ultrasonic washing machine as a gift. Husband claims he is dangerous and has bad influence per person. If this is true, then can it be used in a room where adults and children do not go?

    Actually, it is not. Ultrasonic laundry detergents, like other ultrasonic home appliances(e.g. ultrasonic humidifiers) are quite safe. And if the devices are used in a room where adults and children do not go, then they are doubly safe. The harm of ultrasound has been proven with its regular (daily, many hours) exposure to the tissues of the human body. Not without reason, after all, doctors who constantly work on ultrasound diagnostic devices receive a premium for harmfulness. But the episodic direct effect of ultrasound on the human body and the systematic indirect effect (that is, not on a person, but on an object or air with which a person will then come into contact) is not at all harmful.

    The child fell ill - 1 year 3 months. Symptoms - runny nose, cough, temperature 37.6. A week ago we were presented with an air humidifier - we have been constantly using it to this day. The husband and mother-in-law state that the child has become ill because of the humidifier and that the use of the humidifier should be stopped immediately. Are they right?

    Symptoms of runny nose, cough and fever These are signs of a viral infection. What does the humidifier have to do with viruses and their entry into the body of a child is not clear. The main thing is that the humidifier does not just work, but that you control the humidity in the room. Humidity should be between 50 and 70%. Those. Once again, I draw your attention: it is not the fact of the operation of the humidifier that is important, but the work to achieve a very specific goal.

    Information taken from the official website of Dr. V. Komarovsky